Franchising in the pizza industry remains one of the most appealing ways to enter the restaurant business. The demand for high-quality, quick-service pizza continues to grow, and both Antioch Pizza Shop and Toppers Pizza have carved out strong reputations with unique approaches to flavor, brand identity, and franchise flexibility.
If you’re evaluating pizza franchise opportunities and wondering which of these two brands is a better fit for you, this guide breaks it down – from investment and support to growth potential and ideal ownership fit – using publicly available, accurate 2025 information.
Brand Overview: Antioch Pizza Shop vs. Toppers Pizza
Antioch Pizza Shop
Founded in 1977 in Antioch, Illinois, Antioch Pizza Shop has grown from a local favorite into a regional franchise opportunity built on community, consistency, and comfort. Known for its motto, “The Crust of the Community,” Antioch balances small-town authenticity with operational simplicity.
Today, the brand offers four flexible formats – dine-in, takeout/delivery, express, and food truck – designed for varying investment levels and ownership styles.
Toppers Pizza
Founded in 1991, Toppers Pizza is known for its bold flavors, irreverent marketing, and late-night culture. Franchising began in 1997, and the brand now has locations across several U.S. states.
Toppers markets itself as a delivery-first, high-volume pizza brand with a loyal college-town following. Its “Never Settle” approach focuses on innovation, strong franchise support, and operational consistency.
Franchise Investment Comparison
| Category | Antioch Pizza Shop | Toppers Pizza |
|---|---|---|
| Initial Franchise Fee | $20,000–$40,000 (varies by format) | $30,000 plus $7,500 project management fee |
| Initial Investment Range | $106,500–$729,325 (format-dependent) | $510,000 – $690,285 |
| Royalty Fee | 5% of gross sales | 5.5% of gross sales |
| Advertising/Marketing Fee | 1% of gross sales | 3% of gross sales |
| Franchise Term | 10 years | 10 years |
| Training & Support | Comprehensive onboarding, local marketing, and operational training | Extensive multi-week training, field support, and national marketing |
Analysis:
- Antioch Pizza Shop offers lower startup costs, especially with the Express or Food Truck formats, making it more accessible for first-time franchisees or semi-absentee owners.
- Toppers Pizza is a more traditional restaurant franchise investment, with standardized store models and higher initial capital requirements.
Format Flexibility
Antioch Pizza Shop’s biggest differentiator is flexibility. Franchisees can select from four models:
- Traditional Dine-In / Takeout / Delivery
- Takeout & Delivery Only
- Express Restaurant
- Food Truck / Mobile Unit
This flexibility allows new owners to start with smaller investments and scale up over time.
Toppers Pizza offers one standardized restaurant format, typically 1,400–1,600 sq. ft., optimized for high-volume delivery and carryout. While proven, this model requires a greater upfront investment and a full-time commitment from the owner or operator.
Support and Operations
Antioch Pizza Shop
- Personalized onboarding and franchisee support
- Marketing materials and community partnership guidance
- Real estate selection assistance
- Menu flexibility and local customization options
- Option for part-time or semi-absentee ownership
Toppers Pizza
- Centralized marketing and tech-driven delivery system
- In-depth training program at “Toppers University”
- Proprietary POS and online ordering platforms
- Field operations team support
- More national advertising infrastructure
Brand Culture and Consumer Appeal
Antioch Pizza Shop:
- Family-oriented, community-driven, nostalgic branding
- Focus on handcrafted pizzas, sandwiches, and desserts
- Broad demographic appeal – suburban, family, and small-town markets
- Promotes local engagement and fundraisers
Toppers Pizza:
- Younger, energetic, bold brand voice
- Appeals to college towns, urban areas, and late-night customers
- Menu features signature flavors and creative toppings (“Wisconsin Curds ‘N Bacon,” “Buffalo Chicken”)
- Emphasizes digital ordering and fast delivery
In short:
Antioch fits best in growing suburban and community-based markets like Tampa, Nashville, or Raleigh. Toppers thrives in college towns and dense urban markets with heavy delivery traffic.
Final Take: Antioch Pizza Shop vs. Toppers Pizza
Both brands deliver strong business models, but the right fit depends on your goals.
- Choose Antioch Pizza Shop if you want an affordable, community-driven, and flexible franchise that allows entry at multiple levels (including food truck or express). It’s perfect for semi-absentee owners or those entering franchising for the first time.
- Choose Toppers Pizza if you have the capital to invest in a more established, delivery-centric brand with higher average unit volume and structured national systems.
Both offer paths to profitability, but Antioch Pizza Shop stands out for its approachable investment, family atmosphere, and adaptability – a major advantage in today’s evolving franchise landscape.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. How much does it cost to open an Antioch Pizza Shop franchise?
The investment varies by format:
- Food Truck: $106,500–$196,825
- Express Restaurant: $108,500–$352,900
- Full-Service Restaurant: $226,900–$729,325
Each includes the franchise fee, build-out, equipment, and startup capital.
2. How much does it cost to open a Toppers Pizza franchise?
Toppers Pizza’s total investment ranges between $510,000 and $690,285 with a $30,000 franchise fee and royalty of 5.5%.
3. Which franchise offers more flexibility for new owners?
Antioch Pizza Shop wins here – with four ownership formats and the option to start part-time or full-time.
Toppers Pizza offers one standardized store model, which requires a full-time owner or manager.
4. Can I own multiple units with either brand?
Yes. Both Antioch and Toppers support multi-unit ownership, but Antioch’s lower costs can make it easier for franchisees to scale faster within a region.
5. What kind of franchisee is Antioch Pizza Shop looking for?
Antioch seeks franchisees who are passionate about food, family, and community engagement. You don’t need prior restaurant experience – the brand provides comprehensive training and operational support.
6. Which franchise offers a better work-life balance?
Because of its format flexibility, Antioch Pizza Shop offers better work-life balance options. Food truck or express models can be semi-absentee or run with minimal staff, allowing owners to maintain other income streams.
Conclusion
When comparing Antioch Pizza Shop vs. Toppers Pizza, both offer exciting opportunities – but the best choice depends on your capital, goals, and lifestyle.
If you’re looking for an affordable, flexible, and community-oriented pizza business that can grow with you, Antioch Pizza Shop may be your perfect slice of the franchise world.
We’re excited to hear from you!
To start a conversation, fill out our simple online application. A member of our franchising team will be in touch shortly with more information about your opportunity as an Antioch Pizza franchise owner.
